Skip to content
CapRadio

CapRadio

listen live donate
listen live donate
listen live
donate
  • News
    • News

    • State Government
    • Environment
    • Health Care
    • Race and Equity
    • Business
    • Arts and Lifestyle
    • Food and Sustainability
    • PolitiFact California
    News
    • News

    • State Government
    • Environment
    • Health Care
    • Race and Equity
    • Business
    • Arts and Lifestyle
    • Food and Sustainability
    • PolitiFact California
  • Music
    • Music

    • Classical
    • Jazz
    • Eclectic

    • Daily Playlist
    Music
    • Music

    • Classical
    • Jazz
    • Eclectic

    • Daily Playlist
  • Podcasts & Shows
  • Schedules
  • Events
  • Support
    • Support
    • Ways to support
    • Evergreen Donation
    • One-Time Donation
    • Corporate Sponsorship
    • Vehicle Donation
    • Stock Giving
    • Legacy Giving
    • Endowment Support
    • Members
    • Member Benefits
    • Member FAQ
    • Member Newsletter

    • Fund drives
    • Drawing Winners
    • Thank You Gifts
    Support
    • Support
    • Ways to support
    • Evergreen Donation
    • One-Time Donation
    • Corporate Sponsorship
    • Vehicle Donation
    • Stock Giving
    • Legacy Giving
    • Endowment Support
    • Members
    • Member Benefits
    • Member FAQ
    • Member Newsletter

    • Fund drives
    • Drawing Winners
    • Thank You Gifts
  • About
  • Close Menu

California Dream

 

A statewide collaboration between Capital Public Radio, KQED, KPCC, KPBS and CALmatters focused on key issues of economic opportunity, quality of life and the future of the “California Dream.”

Series and Project Archive

 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 
 We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter 

Income Experiment Offers Stockton Residents a Glimpse at the California Dream

  •  Sammy Caiola 
Thursday, October 3, 2019 | Sacramento, CA
Listen
/
Update RequiredTo play audio, update browser or Flash plugin.
Andrew Nixon / CapRadio

Then-Stockton Mayor Michael Tubbs, 29, stands in front of city hall in 2019.

Andrew Nixon / CapRadio

Michael Tubbs remembers watching his mother strain to make ends meet in his childhood home in Stockton. 

“At the end of the month, it took magic to make everything pencil out,” he said. “I never saw my mom get a manicure or pedicure growing up. I never saw her take a vacation.”

Now Tubbs, the city’s 29-year-old mayor, is championing a monthly cash aid program that he says could be a game-changer for families like his. 

“There are people in Stockton who are working very hard, who are still struggling,” he said. “That idea of increasing opportunity and breaking cycles of poverty is probably the crux of all the work we’re doing.”

Stockton is one of two U.S. cities experimenting with universal basic income, the idea of giving all Americans a fixed, no-strings-attached stipend. Proponents say it’s a step toward economic equality, but critics worry a handout will enable bad behavior.

The Stockton program isn’t quite universal — only 125 people were selected to receive the $500 monthly allowance for 18 months. 

Last fall the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration, a collaboration tasked with running the pilot, sent 4,200 mailers to randomly selected households in neighborhoods where the city’s median income is at or below $46,033. Program organizers randomly selected the participants from the 478 residents who completed a survey.  Another 200 people were randomly chosen to participate in the research without receiving a monthly stipend. That control group is receiving gift cards in exchange for sharing information about their lives and financial well-being. 

Following The Money

Project researchers just released the first cache of data showing how recipients spent their money in the first five months of the program, which began in February. 

Roughly 40% of purchases on the prepaid debit cards went to food, 24% went to home goods and clothing, and 11% paid for utilities, according to the report. The group did not track the 40% of funds that were transferred to savings, checking, or cash. 

Tubbs said the data proves that Stockton residents are using the money to better themselves and their families.

“For so long, people have looked at Stockton for examples of what things are bad,” he said. “But this is one of a couple of examples where people are looking at Stockton for solutions “

Most of the project’s $3 million budget comes from a private foundation called the Economic Security Project, launched three years ago with help from Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes. The foundation selected Stockton, a city once labeled America’s foreclosure capital, as a guinea pig because of its diverse racial  and economic profile, said project co-founder Natalie Foster.

“It really looks like America,” she said. “It’s a city that’s reinventing itself, that’s pulling out of that bankruptcy, and leaning into its pluralistic community to build what’s next.”

Astronomical Costs

The universal income concept has been bubbling up in national politics, with Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang promising $1,000 a month to every American regardless of income level, and Kamala Harris, a U.S. senator from California, pushing for roughly $6,000 a year in refundable tax credits to lower-income Americans.

But experts say the costs of implementing basic income on a large scale would be astronomical. A recent report from UC Berkeley estimated giving every American a $1,000 a month would cost roughly $3 trillion per year, or 75% of total current federal spending. 

Even eliminating Medicaid, Social Security Income and other staples of the current safety net system wouldn’t even out that deficit, said economist and report author Jesse Rothstein. Although the monthly stipend would give individuals more control over how they receive and spend aid, it wouldn’t be robust enough to cover basic expenses, Rothstein said. 

“What that would amount to is really dramatically reducing the standard of living of the elderly and disabled in order to finance a transfer to prime-age, healthy people,” he said. “There’s no way that an elderly person is going to be able to buy decent health insurance on the private market with that $1,000 dollar a month UBI [Universal Basic Income] and still be able to have any money left over for anything else.” 

But many supporters say basic income should be an addition to the current safety net, not a replacement for it . There’s also the question of whether a cash giveaway dissuades people from working. Some see it as a hand up for the working poor, while others say it’s a cushion for those who choose not to work.

“Everybody’s talking about a program with the same name, but they have different ideas about what it would look like,” Rothstein said. 

Breathing Room

In Stockton, the $500 allowance is giving Jovan Bravo a little breathing room. He usually works 68 hours a week — including regular Saturday shifts — to support his family. Since the stipend started coming in, he’s been able to work a little less without stressing about paying the bills. That means more time with his wife and his three kids, ages 13, 9 and 4. 

He says he’s also been able to cover some extracurriculars for them, such as basketball camp and gymnastics class. He worries that without activities to keep them busy, they could be exposed to crime when they get older. Bravo, 31, was arrested on drug and weapon charges in his early 20’s but said he’s determined to put his kids on a better path.

“I always hold my kids to a higher standard than what I was held to,” he said. “I want them to be like their mother, go to college, get their master’s, get a good paying job and not have to work as many hours as me. I don't want them to be the hardworking blue collar individual.”

Jovan Bravo, 31, at the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration headquarters. Bravo is one of 125 residents receiving $500 a month from the pilot project.Sammy Caiola

 

Forty-three percent of the Stockton participants receiving the stipend are employed full or part time, according to the report, and 20% are disabled, 11% are caregivers and another 11% are looking for work. Females make up 70% of the participants. 

The racial breakdown shows 47% of the participants are white, 37% are Hispanic, Latino or Spanish origin and 28% are black. The average median monthly income for recipients, without the stipend,  is $1,800.

Rothstein says pilots like the one in Stockton aren’t the most accurate tool for predicting the potential effects of basic income on the labor market, because people won’t make major life changes when the income bump is temporary.

“They just can’t be transformative at this scale, you’d have to scale them up by many orders of magnitude to have the kinds of impacts we’re talking about, and nobody has figured out how to pay for that,” he said. 

Happier, Healthier Cities?

Rothstein and the SEED researchers found, unsurprisingly, that people receiving a regular stipend were happier, and less stressed.They spend more time with their families and pay more attention to their health when they’re not constantly preoccupied with finances. 

Bravo is accustomed to planning every expenditure months in advance, from setting aside money for birthday gifts to saving for family vacations. He says he’s still a careful calculator, but the extra money has allowed him to take a break. 

“It’s made me a lot happier,” he said. “It’s hard working so many long days back to back, six days a week. I enjoy not having to work Saturdays, get to rest, get a full two days off of work. It’s a big relief.”

And Mayor Tubbs believes reducing the hardships of individuals and families will ultimately improve the city on the whole. He’s planning major downtown beautification projects and pushing job and education opportunities for low-income residents. 

“When folks have their bills paid, they’re more likely to volunteer, they’re more likely to be able to vote, they’re more likely to attend city council meetings,” he said. “They’re more likely to have a positive feeling about themselves and their neighborhood.”

Chicago is currently designing its own experiment around Stockton’s pilot.  A city task force in February proposed giving 1,000 qualified residents $1,000 a month for 18 months. The money would come from private donations..


Follow us for more stories like this

CapRadio provides a trusted source of news because of you.  As a nonprofit organization, donations from people like you sustain the journalism that allows us to discover stories that are important to our audience. If you believe in what we do and support our mission, please donate today.

Donate Today  

    Related Stories

  • Eric Risberg / AP Photo

    Bloomberg Unveils Proposals On Housing, Income Inequality During Stockton Campaign Stop

    Wednesday, December 11, 2019
    Democratic presidential candidate Michael Bloomberg also received an endorsement from Stockton Mayor Michael Tubbs.

 CADream

Andrew Nixon / CapRadio

Sammy Caiola

Former Healthcare Reporter

Sammy Caiola has been covering medical breakthroughs, fitness fads and health policy in California since 2014. Before joining CapRadio, Sammy was a health reporter at The Sacramento Bee.  Read Full Bio 

 @sammycaiola Email Sammy Caiola

Sign up for ReCap and never miss the top stories

Delivered to your inbox every Friday.

 

Check out a sample ReCap newsletter.

Thanks for subscribing!

Thank you for signing up for the ReCap newsletter! We'll send you an email each Friday with the top stories from CapRadio.

Browse all newsletters

More California Dream Stories

Andrew Nixon / Capital Public Radio

California Dream: Exploring The Promise — And Unintended Consequences — of Rent Control

June 21, 2018

Amita Sharma / KPBS

The Risks Of Energy Efficient Loans

November 27, 2018

Elizabeth Aguilera/CALmatters

Living In One Of The Most Polluted Places In California

January 30, 2019

View All California Dream Stories  

Most Viewed

California coronavirus updates: Las Vegas airport reports record passenger volume in 2022

Black educators in California say state budget reaffirms Black students don’t matter

10 new California laws that go into effect in 2023

In Turkey and Syria, outdated building methods all but assured disaster from a quake

How a new law is bringing more attention to natural carbon sequestration

We Get Support From:
Become a Supporter

Most Viewed

California coronavirus updates: Las Vegas airport reports record passenger volume in 2022

Black educators in California say state budget reaffirms Black students don’t matter

10 new California laws that go into effect in 2023

In Turkey and Syria, outdated building methods all but assured disaster from a quake

How a new law is bringing more attention to natural carbon sequestration

Back to Top

  • CapRadio

    7055 Folsom Boulevard
    Sacramento, CA 95826-2625

    •  
      (916) 278-8900
    •  
      (877) 480-5900
    •  Contact / Feedback
    •  Submit a News Tip
  • About

    • Mission / Vision / Core Values
    • Stations & Coverage Map
    • Careers & Internships
    • Staff Directory
    • Board of Directors
    • Press
  • Listening Options

    • Mobile Apps
    • Smart Speakers
    • Podcasts & Shows
    • On-Air Schedules
    • Daily Playlist
    • Signal Status
  • Connect

    •  Facebook
    •  Twitter
    •  Instagram
    •  YouTube
  • Donate

  • Listen Live

  • Newsletters

CapRadio stations are licensed to California State University, Sacramento. © 2023, Capital Public Radio. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Website Feedback FCC Public Files: KXJZ KKTO KUOP KQNC KXPR KXSR KXJS. For assistance accessing our public files, please call 916-278-8900 or email us.